What cocktail can I make with dark rum and butterscotch schnapps?

Cocktail Colin says:

quote start
I have found a cocktail called "Pirate Milk" that uses dark rum and butterscotch schnapps as its main ingredients. It's a cold, alcoholic cocktail served in a lowball glass. This cocktail has a rating of 2.24/5.
quote end
 Send this to a friend:

On this page

  • · · · · · ·   Answer
  • · · · · · ·   The cocktails
  • · · · · · ·   FAQ's


Dark rum

You asked: Cocktails with dark rum and butterscotch schnapps. We found 10 cocktails answering the question.

Hot Buttered Rum

The Hot Buttered Rum is a classic warm cocktail that exudes comfort and richness, perfect for cold weather or festive...

White rum (60ml), Nutmeg (Pinch), Honey (10ml), Butter (Teaspoon)

4 ingredients
4.6 / 5


This recipe was originally featured by Binging With Babish on YouTube, for a Harry Potter-themed video. It's a delicious recipe...

Butterscotch schnapps (60ml), Cream (30ml), Sugar Syrup (15ml), Vanilla Essence (Dash), Egg (1 egg white)

5 ingredients
3.98 / 5

Pirate Milk

Pirate Milk is a rich and decadent cocktail that combines the boldness of dark rum with the sweet, caramel-like flavor...

Dark rum (30ml), Butterscotch schnapps (30ml), Amarula Cream (30ml)

3 ingredients
3.87 / 5

Morphine Drip

The Morphine Drip cocktail is a potent concoction that combines sweet and rich flavors with a sturdy alcoholic backbone. This...

Butterscotch schnapps (15ml), Amaretto (15ml), Overproof rum (15ml)

3 ingredients
3.79 / 5

Sherbet Schnapps

This drink tastes like sherbet. Though you can’t taste the alcohol, it has over half a pint of schnapps in...

Raspberry schnapps (120ml), Lemonade (Top up), Butterscotch schnapps (120ml), Apple schnapps (120ml)

4 ingredients
3.66 / 5

Hot Rum Chocolate

The Hot Rum Chocolate cocktail is a warm, indulgent drink perfect for colder months or as a comforting dessert beverage....

Dark rum (30ml), Whipped Cream (Top up), Hot chocolate (50ml)

3 ingredients
3.65 / 5


The Werther's cocktail is a blend of sweetness and strength, combining the rich, caramel-like flavors of butterscotch schnapps with the...

Butterscotch schnapps (7.5ml), Whiskey (22.5ml)

2 ingredients
3.64 / 5

The Butt Krak

Adding butterscotch schnapps and Kraken dark rum together with a splash of coke, creates the delicious Butt Krak.

Cola (240ml), Dark rum (30ml), Butterscotch schnapps (30ml)

3 ingredients
3.6 / 5

Caramel Apple Martini

The Caramel Apple Martini is a dessert-inspired cocktail that offers a sweet twist on the classic martini. The drink is...

Butterscotch schnapps (30ml), Apple vodka (30ml), Apple schnapps (30ml), Caramel Syrup (Dash)

4 ingredients
3.52 / 5


We've collated some quick fire Q&A's on the question to help you find exactly what you're looking for.

question icon image

What is dark rum?

Dark rum is a type of rum that is aged longer and has a richer, more complex flavor compared to light or golden rums. It is often used in cocktails for added depth of flavor.

question icon image

What is butterscotch schnapps?

Butterscotch schnapps is a sweet, flavored liqueur that tastes like butterscotch candy. It is commonly used in cocktails to add a buttery, caramel-like flavor.

question icon image

Can dark rum and butterscotch schnapps be mixed in a hot cocktail?

Yes, dark rum and butterscotch schnapps can be mixed in hot cocktails. They pair well in drinks such as hot buttered rum and other warm beverages.

question icon image

What kind of glass is best for serving cocktails with dark rum?

The type of glass depends on the cocktail. For example, dark rum cocktails are often served in lowball glasses, highball glasses, or even mugs for hot beverages.

question icon image

What are some common mixers for dark rum?

Common mixers for dark rum include cola, ginger beer, pineapple juice, and various citrus juices. These mixers complement the rich, molasses-like flavor of dark rum.

build your bar

Create a cocktail

Choose a theme and some ingredients, give us some description and we'll create an amazing cocktail for you.

Register as a Premium Make Me A Cocktail community member and get access to an even more powerful creator.

Start creating

Build your bar

Tell us what you have at home and we’ll find a delicious cocktail for you to make right now.

Register as a Make Me A Cocktail community member and we’ll save your ingredients list so you can come back to it at any time.

Create My Bar
build your bar