What cocktails can I make with rum, brandy, pineapple juice, orange juice, orgeat syrup, and fire?

It sounds like you're in the mood for a multi-faceted cocktail with a bit of drama! Based on your preference for rum, brandy, pineapple juice, orange juice, orgeat syrup, and wanting a bit of flair with fire, the cocktail that fits your desires closely is the "Rum Runner." While the classic recipe does not include orgeat syrup or the fire element, you can easily adapt it to meet your tastes.

The Rum Runner is known for its vibrant blend of tropical flavors. It combines pineapple juice and orange juice with both white and dark rums, and includes a dash of grenadine, banana liqueur, and blackberry brandy, making it a well-rounded drink with multiple layers of fruitiness. The grenadine adds a lovely touch of color and a hint of pomegranate richness. You can simply add a teaspoon of orgeat syrup to introduce a subtle almond flavor, which will add an extra complexity to the overall profile.

To incorporate the fire element, you could float a high-proof rum on top and carefully ignite it right before serving—just be sure to exercise caution and safety when doing so. This extra touch will certainly up the presentation and make for an unforgettable drink experience.

For a tropical and slightly theatrical drink, the Rum Runner, with a couple of tweaks, would be a fantastic choice. Enjoy your mixology adventure!