What's a good rum nightcap?

Cocktail Colin says:
I have found a selection of rum-based cocktails that could serve as a great nightcap. Based on ratings, I would suggest starting with the cocktail that has a rating of 4.7/5, followed by the ones rated at 4.56/5 and 4.29/5 for a delicious and satisfying nightcap experience.
On this page
-
· · · · · · Answer
-
· · · · · · The cocktails
-
· · · · · · FAQ's
Tag
Menu creation
Do you want to create an online or printable menu with these cocktails in for your next party or gathering. We can pre-fill the cocktail results here into your own personalised menu.
You asked: Best rum nightcap cocktails. We found 10 cocktails answering the question.
Rum Collins
The Rum Collins is a refreshing and classic cocktail that is perfect for a hot summer day. It has a...
Lime 1, White rum 60ml, Soda water Top up, Sugar Teaspoon
Martin's Rum
Martin's Rum is a warm and potent cocktail that combines the citrusy tang of lime, orange, and lemon juices with...
Lime juice 22.5ml, Orange juice 45ml, Lemon Juice 22.5ml, Dark rum 37.5ml, Whiskey 7.5ml, Sugar / simple Syrup 10ml, Sugar Teaspoon, Overproof rum 37.5ml
Rum Fireball
This fiery shooter packs a deadly punch with the cinnamon schnapps and Tabasco sauce. Great for some hot fun, but...
White rum 22.5ml, Tabasco Sauce Dash, Cinnamon shcnapps 22.5ml
Sweet Captain
For when you're out of Gosling's Black Seal, or when you feel that your variation of Dark'n'Stormy is missing just...
Grenadine 15ml, Black rum 45ml, Ginger Beer 120ml
Rum Buck
The Rum Buck is a cocktail that combines the rich, complex flavors of both white and dark rum, with a...
Cointreau 15ml, White rum 30ml, Lemon Juice 7.5ml, Ginger Ale 120ml, Dark rum 22.5ml
Maple Rummy
This New Years Eve, I plan on making my favourite fancy cocktail to toast to with - a rummy variation....
Dark rum 15ml, Lime juice Dash, White wine 90ml, Maple Syrup 15ml
Rum Flame
The Rum Flame cocktail is a fiery drink that combines the rich, bold flavors of dark rum with a touch...
Dark rum 90ml, Sugar Teaspoon, Orange liqueur Dash
Chocolate Rum
The Chocolate Rum cocktail is a sumptuous blend that marries the rich, velvety notes of chocolate with the deep, complex...
Orange juice 30ml, Dark rum 30ml, Creme De Cacao 60ml
Nightcap
The Nightcap cocktail is a comforting, warm beverage that's perfect for unwinding after a long day. As its name suggests,...
Dark rum 60ml, Milk 120ml, Sugar / simple Syrup Teaspoon
Rum Runner
The Rum Runner is a fruity and tropical cocktail that captures the essence of the Caribbean. Traditionally served in a...
Pineapple Juice 30ml, Orange juice 30ml, White rum 30ml, Dark rum 30ml, Grenadine Dash, Banana liqueur (crème de banane) 30ml, Blackberry Brandy 30ml
FAQ's
We've collated some quick fire Q&A's on the question to help you find exactly what you're looking for.

What makes a good nightcap cocktail?
A good nightcap cocktail is usually strong, smooth, and slightly sweet, providing a relaxing finish to the evening.

Can rum be used in a nightcap?
Yes, rum can be an excellent choice for a nightcap due to its rich and warming flavors.

What type of rum is best for a nightcap?
Dark rum is often preferred for nightcaps because of its deep, complex flavors that are well-suited to relaxing drinks.

Are there any simple rum nightcap recipes?
Yes, simple recipes like rum and milk or a rum old-fashioned can serve as excellent nightcaps.

How can I make my rum nightcap more flavorful?
You can enhance the flavor of your rum nightcap by adding ingredients like spices, syrups, or other liqueurs.

Create a cocktail
Choose a theme and some ingredients, give us some description and we'll create an amazing cocktail for you.
Register as a Premium Make Me a Cocktail community member and get access to an even more powerful creator.
Start creatingBuild your bar
Tell us what you have at home and we’ll find a delicious cocktail for you to make right now.
Register as a Make Me a Cocktail community member and we’ll save your ingredients list so you can come back to it at any time.
Create My Bar