What goes well with Screwball?

Cocktail Colin says:

quote start
I have found a cocktail that includes whiskey and peanut butter flavors, which might complement Screwball peanut butter whiskey. This cocktail has a good rating and includes ingredients that could pair nicely with Screwball.
quote end
 Send this to a friend:

On this page

  • · · · · · ·   Answer
  • · · · · · ·   The cocktails
  • · · · · · ·   FAQ's


Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey

You asked: What pairs well with Screwball peanut butter whiskey?. We found 10 cocktails answering the question.

Slow Comfortable Screw

This combo is right for any time, as a pick me up on a hot day, or before or after...

Orange juice (300ml), Whiskey (100ml), Angostura Bitters (Dash), Sloe Gin (100ml)

4 ingredients
3.89 / 5

Rusty Screw

The rusty screw originates from exchanging the orange peel used in a Rusty Nail for orange liqueur. The Frangelico was...

Cointreau (15ml), Frangelico (15ml), Drambuie (30ml), Whiskey (30ml)

4 ingredients
3.82 / 5

Vanilla Screwdriver

The Vanilla Screwdriver is a sweet twist on the classic Screwdriver cocktail, which typically combines orange juice with vodka. In...

Orange juice (Top up), Vanilla vodka (60ml)

2 ingredients
3.82 / 5

Nutty Sam

The Nutty Sam is a straightforward cocktail that marries the robust warmth of whiskey with the sweet, almond-like notes of...

Whiskey (60ml), Amaretto (30ml)

2 ingredients
3.66 / 5

Curtis's Nut Butter

The Curtis's Nut Butter cocktail is a rich, creamy concoction that combines the sweet, caramel flavor of butterscotch schnapps with...

Butterscotch schnapps (45ml), Amaretto (45ml), Milk (Top up)

3 ingredients
3.63 / 5

Buttery Nipple

The Buttery Nipple is a popular and creamy cocktail that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. This indulgent drink...

Bailey's (30ml), Butterscotch schnapps (30ml)

2 ingredients
3.58 / 5

Celtic Screw

The Celtic Screw is a rich and decadent cocktail that combines the smooth creaminess of Bailey's Irish Cream with the...

Bailey's (30ml), Drambuie (30ml), Whiskey (30ml)

3 ingredients
3.57 / 5

Peanut Butter & Jelly

The Peanut Butter & Jelly cocktail is a unique, nostalgia-inducing concoction that evokes the flavors of the classic childhood sandwich....

Bailey's (15ml), Cranberry Juice (Top up), Frangelico (15ml)

3 ingredients
3.53 / 5

Screwed Up Screwdriver

The Screwed Up Screwdriver is a tantalizing twist on the classic Screwdriver cocktail. Traditionally a simple combination of vodka and...

Black Vodka (45ml), Orange juice (150ml)

2 ingredients
3.53 / 5

Nutty Jack

The Nutty Jack cocktail is a decadent concoction that artfully combines the warmth of whiskey with the sweetness of Nutella,...

Cointreau (7.5 ml), Orange juice (60ml), Whiskey (30ml), Amaretto (22.5ml), Nutella (2 teaspoons)

5 ingredients
3.53 / 5


We've collated some quick fire Q&A's on the question to help you find exactly what you're looking for.

question icon image

What flavors mix well with peanut butter whiskey?

Flavors like chocolate, banana, and coffee mix well with peanut butter whiskey, creating rich and dessert-like cocktails.

question icon image

Can you make a simple cocktail with Screwball whiskey?

Yes, a simple mix of Screwball whiskey with cola, or over ice creates a delicious and easy-to-make cocktail.

question icon image

Is Screwball whiskey suitable for shots?

Yes, Screwball peanut butter whiskey is popular for shots, often enjoyed on its own or with a sweet chaser like chocolate liqueur.

question icon image

Are there non-alcoholic mixers that go well with Screwball whiskey?

Non-alcoholic mixers like vanilla soda, cream soda, or even root beer pair well with Screwball whiskey, enhancing its nutty flavor.

question icon image

What dessert recipes can include Screwball whiskey?

Screwball whiskey can be included in desserts like whiskey-infused brownies, peanut butter whiskey milkshakes, or as a drizzle over vanilla ice cream.

build your bar

Create a cocktail

Choose a theme and some ingredients, give us some description and we'll create an amazing cocktail for you.

Register as a Premium Make Me A Cocktail community member and get access to an even more powerful creator.

Start creating

Build your bar

Tell us what you have at home and we’ll find a delicious cocktail for you to make right now.

Register as a Make Me A Cocktail community member and we’ll save your ingredients list so you can come back to it at any time.

Create My Bar
build your bar