The 10 best Amaro cocktails
An editorial shortlist of the Amaro cocktails most worth starting with.
Introduction
Amaro Cocktails: Bold and Herbal Indulgence
Amaro, the Italian herbal liqueur, offers a complex tapestry of flavors that has captivated cocktail enthusiasts around the world.
With its bittersweet profile, this versatile ingredient serves as the perfect companion for a variety of spirits, adding depth and character to any drink. Whether you're a seasoned mixologist or a curious novice, this listicle will guide you through the top 10 cocktails that highlight the nuanced flavors of Amaro. From the zesty 'Mucho Grande' to the rich and warming 'Winter Waltz,' these recipes promise to elevate your cocktail game and impress your guests with their unique flavors and sophisticated appeal. Typically containing a blend of herbs, roots, flowers, and spices, Amaro is known for its slightly bitter and complex flavor profile.
It can range from light and citrusy to dark and syrupy, making it an incredibly diverse ingredient for various types of cocktails. Below, you'll find a selection of concoctions that not only celebrate the distinct character of Amaro but also provide a delightful drinking experience for any occasion.
On this page
Jump through the ranked list, then head into the conclusion or FAQs.
1. Mucho Grande
This cocktail combines a medley of citrus flavors, with orange juice and lemon juice providing a zesty backdrop. The caramel syrup adds a layer of sweetness, beautifully counterbalanced by the herbal notes of Amaro. Tequila brings a robust spirit foundation, while Aperol adds a hint of bitterness that complements the Amaro perfectly. The egg white adds a smooth, velvety texture, making this a well-rounded and refreshing drink ideal for any occasion.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Add all the ingredients including the egg white to shaker with ice and shake until the outside of the shaker becomes frosted
-
- Strain over ice into a rocks glass
-
- Garnish with an orange twist and a cherry and serve
2. Winter Waltz
This cocktail is a warm and inviting drink perfect for colder months. It marries the spicy notes of Angostura Bitters and Allspice Dram with the rich, caramel undertones of rye whiskey. Amaro adds a layer of complexity, with its herbal and slightly bitter notes enhancing the overall flavor profile. The combination creates a harmonious blend that's both comforting and sophisticated, making it a perfect wintertime sipper.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Add the whisky, amaro, allspice and bitters to a cocktail shaker with ice
-
- Shake firmly until the outside of the shaker becomes frosted, before straining into a chilled martini glass
-
- Garnish with a star anise and serve
3. On The Bright Side
This cocktail offers a delightful mix of flavors, from the fruitiness of port to the spiciness of rye whiskey. The addition of DOM Benedictine adds a layer of herbal complexity, which is beautifully enhanced by the Amaro. A dash of orange bitters ties everything together, resulting in a bright and lively drink that's perfect for any occasion. The multifaceted flavors make it both intriguing and satisfying, appealing to a wide range of palates.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Rinse a chilled martini glass with the Scotch
-
- Next combine the other ingredients in a mixing glass with ice
-
- Stir and strain into the rinsed glass before garnishing with an orange twist and serving
4. MonteNegroni
This cocktail is a riff on the classic Negroni but replaces the traditional Campari with Amaro, giving it a more complex and herbal profile. The combination of red vermouth, dry gin, and Amaro creates a balanced, bittersweet drink that's both refreshing and complex. It's a sophisticated choice for those who enjoy a well-crafted cocktail with a touch of bitter elegance.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Begin by stirring all the ingredients together with ice in a mixing glass, ensuring a well-blended mixture
-
- Aim to stir for about 10-15 seconds to reach the perfect dilution and chill
-
- Once sufficiently mixed, strain the blend into a pre-chilled glass to preserve its cool temperature
-
- This process will remove the ice, leaving you with a smooth, chilled cocktail, ready to enjoy
5. Midnight Stinger
This cocktail is a bold and refreshing drink that's perfect for late-night sipping. Bourbon provides a strong and warming base, while sugar syrup and lemon juice offer a balance of sweetness and acidity. The Amaro adds a herbal and slightly bitter complexity, making this cocktail both invigorating and satisfying. It's a great choice for those who enjoy a drink with depth and character.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Begin by adding all of the ingredients into a cocktail shaker, then fill it with ice cubes to cool the mixture evenly
-
- Secure the lid on the shaker and give it a vigorous shake for about 10-15 seconds, or until you notice the shaker's exterior becoming frosted, indicating the ingredients are well-chilled
-
- Next, take a glass and fill it to the brim with crushed ice to prepare it for your cocktail
-
- Carefully strain the shaken mixture from the shaker into the prepared glass, ensuring no ice cubes escape into your beautifully crafted drink
-
- Enjoy your expertly mixed cocktail, ideally served immediately to savor the blend of flavors and the refreshing chill
6. Hanky Panky
This classic cocktail is a delicious blend of gin and red vermouth, with a dash of Amaro adding a herbal and slightly bitter twist. The combination creates a balanced and sophisticated drink that's perfect for any occasion. It's a great choice for those who enjoy a well-crafted cocktail with a touch of bitter elegance.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Stir ingredients well in a mixing glass with ice and strain into a chilled glass
-
- Twist a small swath of orange peel over the surface of the drink to express the oils then drop the peel in to garnish
7. Island Voodoo
This cocktail is an exotic and flavorful mix that's perfect for adventurous drinkers. Rye whiskey provides a strong and spicy base, while lemon liqueur adds a zesty twist. The Amaro adds a layer of herbal complexity, making this cocktail both intriguing and satisfying. It's a great choice for those who enjoy unique and exotic flavors in their drinks.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Add all the ingredients to a mixing glass and fill with ice
-
- Stir well and strain into a chilled wine glass
-
- Garnish with a flamed orange peel and serve
8. Black Manhattan
This cocktail is a rich and complex blend of flavors that's perfect for those who enjoy a strong and spirit-forward drink. Rye whiskey provides a robust base, while Angostura Bitters and Orange Bitters add layers of spice and citrus. The Amaro adds a herbal and slightly bitter complexity, making this cocktail both intriguing and satisfying. It's a great choice for those who appreciate a well-crafted drink with depth and character.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Begin by stirring all the ingredients together with ice in a mixing glass, making sure to stir for about 10-15 seconds to properly chill and dilute the mix
-
- Once stirred, strain the mixture into a chilled glass to ensure your cocktail is served cold, enhancing its flavors
9. Toronto
This classic cocktail is a harmonious blend of whiskey and Amaro, with a dash of Angostura Bitters adding a spicy kick. Gomme syrup adds a touch of sweetness, making this cocktail both balanced and satisfying. It's a great choice for those who enjoy a well-crafted drink with a touch of bitter elegance and a hint of sweetness.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Combine whisky, fernet, simple syrup, and bitters in a mixing glass and fill with cracked ice
-
- Stir for 20 seconds and strain into chilled cocktail glass
-
- Garnish with an orange slide, then serve
10. Rabo-de-Galo
This cocktail is a refreshing and vibrant mix that's perfect for any occasion. Cachaça provides a bright and fruity base, while red vermouth adds a touch of sweetness. The Amaro adds a herbal complexity, and a dash of grapefruit bitters adds a zesty twist. The combination creates a balanced and lively drink that's both refreshing and satisfying.
Ingredients
Method
-
- Start by choosing your preferred method—throwing, stirring, or shaking all the ingredients together with ice based on the cocktail texture you're aiming for
-
- If stirring or shaking, aim for a duration of 10-15 seconds to perfectly blend the flavors, doing so until the exterior of your mixing container feels chilled
-
- For those opting to throw the cocktail, skillfully pour the mixture back and forth between two mixing glasses, achieving both cooling and aeration without diluting the drink too much
-
- After your chosen mixing method, strain the now unified cocktail components into a glass brimming with fresh ice to ensure a crisp serving temperature
-
- This careful balance of mixing and chilling enhances the drink's character, making each sip a testament to your bartending finesse
Conclusion
The chosen cocktails in this list showcase the versatility and depth that Amaro brings to the table.
From citrusy and refreshing options like 'On The Bright Side' to the more robust and spirit-forward classics like the 'MonteNegroni,' each cocktail was selected based on its unique use of Amaro and its ability to create a memorable drinking experience. The intricate balance of flavors and the historical significance behind many of these drinks make them the top 10 cocktails to consider if you’re looking to explore the world of Amaro. So, the next time you're at a loss for what to mix, let this list serve as your guide to discovering some of the best Amaro-infused cocktails out there.
More about Amaro
What is the most popular cocktail made with amaro?
On makemeacocktail.com, the most popular cocktail featuring amaro is the Mucho Grande. It uses amaro to add bitter-herbal depth and complexity to the drink.
What ingredients pair well with amaro in cocktails?
Amaro pairs well with base spirits like whiskey, gin, and rum, where its bitter-sweet herbal notes can add depth. It also works nicely with citrus (lemon, orange), vermouth, and soda water to balance bitterness and lift aromatics.
How many cocktails can you make with amaro?
There are 36 cocktails on makemeacocktail.com that include amaro as an ingredient. That range reflects how versatile amaro is across different styles of drinks.
What is amaro and what does it taste like?
Amaro is an Italian-style herbal liqueur made by infusing neutral spirit with a blend of herbs, roots, and spices. It typically tastes complex and bittersweet, with layered herbal and spice notes that can vary by brand.
Explore even more about Amaro
Jump back to the discovery hub or the ingredient guide if you want broader context beyond this ranked shortlist.
See every Amaro cocktail in one place
Open the full results page to search, sort, and filter every amaro cocktail beyond this shortlist.
