Black Manhattan Cocktail recipe
Rating
Can you make this?
Add the ingredients you have at home to your My Bar and we'll show you what cocktails you can make. Start off by adding the ingredients you have for this cocktail using the plus icons.
Black Manhattan is a modern riff on the Manhattan that swaps sweet vermouth for amaro, giving the drink a darker, more bitter-leaning edge while keeping the same stirred, spirit-forward silhouette. You’ll find it sits comfortably in the contemporary “black” cocktail wave—classic templates reworked with Italian-style bittersweet liqueurs—so it feels familiar if you love old-school whiskey cocktails, but a little moodier and more complex in the glass.
On the palate, rye whiskey brings a firm, dry backbone that the amaro immediately deepens with bittersweet richness. The aromatic bitters tighten the structure and amplify the whiskey’s intensity, while orange bitters lift the whole drink with a crisp citrus accent that keeps the amaro from feeling heavy. Expect a balanced push-pull between rye’s bite and the amaro’s dark sweetness and bitterness, finishing long and pleasantly bracing.
Serve it in a cocktail glass when you want something sleek, contemplative, and unapologetically grown-up. It’s ideal as a pre-dinner sipper, a late-night pour, or a go-to for Manhattan fans who want less sweetness and more depth without leaving the whiskey-forward lane.
Microbadges
Can you make this?
Add the ingredients you have at home to your My Bar and we'll show you what cocktails you can make. Start off by adding the ingredients you have for this cocktail using the plus icons.
Cocktail Colin says:
Rye whiskey leads with spicy grain and warmth, while amaro brings dark herbal bitterness and a touch of caramelized depth, sharpened by aromatic bitters and lifted by orange bitters’ zesty snap. It works because the amaro’s bitter-sweet backbone reins in the rye’s heat as the bitters stitch everything together, ideal for stirred-drink fans who like their nightcap bracing and complex.
Method
How to make a Black Manhattan
- Rye whiskey 60ml, Amaro 30ml, Aromatic bitters 1 dash, Orange bitters 1 dash
-
- Begin by stirring all the ingredients together with ice in a mixing glass, making sure to stir for about 10-15 seconds to properly chill and dilute the mix
-
- Once stirred, strain the mixture into a chilled glass to ensure your cocktail is served cold, enhancing its flavors
Power tips
Elevate the Black Manhattan with these master mixologist tips
Upgrade to premium
And receive world class tips on how to raise your cocktails to the next level.
Find out more- Choose a high-quality Amaro with a well-balanced herbaceous bitterness, like Averna or Montenegro, to ensure a smooth yet complex flavor.
- Express an orange peel over the drink before serving to add a bright citrus aroma that complements the bitters and Amaro.
- Upgrade to premium to receive even more power tips on this cocktail.
Your private tasting notes
Featured in
FAQ's
What is the origin of the Black Manhattan?
The Black Manhattan is a modern twist on the classic Manhattan cocktail. It was created in the early 21st century by New York mixologist Todd Smith while he was working at Bourbon & Branch in San Francisco. The traditional sweet vermouth is replaced with Amaro, giving it a richer and more herbal profile.
How does the taste of a Black Manhattan differ from a traditional Manhattan?
The key difference lies in the substitution of Amaro for sweet vermouth. This change adds a more complex, bitter, and herbal flavor profile to the Black Manhattan, compared to the sweeter, smoother taste of the traditional Manhattan which leans more on the vermouth's sweetness and the whiskey's warmth.
Can I use any type of whiskey for a Black Manhattan?
While the traditional recipe for a Black Manhattan calls for rye whiskey due to its spicy and fruity notes, you can experiment with other types of whiskey. Bourbon is a common alternative, offering a sweeter and fuller flavor. However, using a whiskey that you enjoy will ensure you like the final cocktail.
What type of Amaro is best suited for a Black Manhattan?
The choice of Amaro can vary greatly as each has its own unique flavor profile. A common choice is Amaro Averna, known for its caramel sweetness balanced with citrus and herbal bitterness, which complements the rye whiskey well. Experimentation is encouraged to find your preferred balance.
Is there a non-alcoholic version of a Black Manhattan?
Yes, a non-alcoholic version can be made by substituting the rye whiskey with a non-alcoholic spirit, such as those designed to mimic the flavor of whiskey, and using a non-alcoholic bitter aperitif in place of Amaro. Orange and Angostura bitters, being alcohol-based but used in very small amounts, might still be acceptable for some, but non-alcoholic bitters are also available.
Upgrade your mixology
Become a member for free taking your cocktail making skills up to level 11. Or become a premium member to rise to cocktail greatness.
- Save your bar forever
- Access to our Cocktail Creator, allowing you to create your own wonderful concoctions.
- Access to Cocktail Colin; ask Cocktail Colin anything on an individual cocktail and he'll give you the answers you need.
- Create personalised cocktail menus for all your events, bars or parties
- Save cocktails to personalised 'Tried' and 'Want to try' lists
- Create and record tasting notes on cocktails
- Create lists of cocktails to share with friends and family
- A personalised MyBar URL, allowing you to share everything you can make with friends
- And much more ... (what to buy next, measurement choices, search personalisation...)
Have you tried our Wordpress Plugin?
Download our plugin and embed cocktail recipes directly onto your own site or blog.
Choose from our whole recipe database, or choose a specific cocktail made with a certain ingredient, and let us place a beautiful recipe on your own site.
Find out moreYou might also like
Experience this historic rye whisky classic with citrus.
Ward 8
Rye whiskey, Orange juice, Lemon juice, Grenadine
Experience this regal blend with whiskey and bitters
Prince of Wales
Rye whiskey, Maraschino cherry liqueur, Champagne / prosecco, Sugar / simple syrup, Aromatic bitters, Pineapple
Experience this sophisticated blend of whiskey and port.
On The Bright Side
Rye whiskey, Whiskey, DOM Benedictine, Amaro, Port, Orange bitters
Experience this timeless blend of rye and vermouth.
Ann Sheridan
Rye whiskey, Cointreau, Red vermouth
Create a cocktail
Choose a theme and some ingredients, give us some description and we'll create an amazing cocktail for you.
Register as a Premium Make Me a Cocktail community member and get access to an even more powerful creator.
Start creatingBuild your bar
Tell us what you have at home and we’ll find a delicious cocktail for you to make right now.
Register as a Make Me a Cocktail community member and we’ll save your ingredients list so you can come back to it at any time.
Create My Bar
Cocktail Colin
Your cocktail expert
Hi! I'm Cocktail Colin
Ask me anything about this cocktail - how to make it, substitutions, variations, or any other questions!
Become a member to access Cocktail Colin
Become a member (for free) to pick Cocktail Colin's cocktail filled brain on everything on this cocktail, from substitutions, if you can use what you have, to serving suggestions and more.
Become a member
Comments