Shaken or Stirred?
The argument about whether to shake or stir cocktails has been an extremely hot topic for years – especially among novel-nosed bookworms and moviegoers. Bartenders, on the other hand, seem to have pretty much developed a method that they tend to stick to despite the latest trend on the best seller list or at the box office.
If you’ve ever looked through a cocktail recipe book, you’ve probably noticed that each recipe comes with specific instructions as to whether it should be shaken or stirred. Are these instructions a random evolutionary result of a big bang that took place behind a bar hundreds of millions of years ago, or could there possibly be some kind of technique at play here?
The answer to this age old question is that there are definite rules about what kinds of drinks should be shaken and what kinds should be stirred. Just like in any art form, however, rules are occasionally broken with a colourful exception or two, so despite what you learn from this article, if the recipe says to do the opposite, it’s probably right. If you are the adventurous or entrepreneurial type, feel free to experiment with your ingredients and mixing styles and possibly even create your own exceptions to the general rules stated below.
As a rule of thumb, cocktails and other mixed drinks are traditionally shaken if they contain eggs, cream, or fruit juice. When a mixed drink is shaken, hundreds of thousands of tiny air bubbles are introduced into its depths. Cocktails containing fruit juice will come out of their shaking with a frothy layer of fun on top. Mixed drinks that contain cream or egg whites will also come away with a layer of foam on top that is similar in appearance to the surface of a lemon meringue pie. Of course, it goes without saying that any cocktails containing carbonated water or soda should not usually be shaken, as this will only cause them to lose their bubbles.
Drinks that are shaken are usually shaken with ice shards or cubes. Shaking a drink with ice tends to lower the drink's temperature at a much faster rate than simply leaving it to sit on the rocks. Once the mixing is completed, the ice may either be left in the drink or strained out.
Cocktails that are most commonly shaken include the Margarita, the Daiquiri, the Whiskey Sour, the Cosmopolitan, and the Ramos Gin Fizz. In the case of the latter, the obligatory club soda is only added after the thorough shaking.
The rule of thumb for stirring states that drinks that are either made completely from alcoholic ingredients or that contain only light mixers should always be stirred. Traditionalists insist that shaking only bruises the spirit of the drink. In this kind of drink, clarity is considered classy, and stirring helps to avoid the appearance of air bubbles and ice shards that might tarnish the clarity of the drink.
Manhattans and Martinis are good examples of drinks that should be stirred not shaken - unless you're James Bond!
Cocktail glass
<p>The Manhattan is a whiskey-and-vermouth classic that sits at the heart of American cocktail culture. Its origins are famously debated, with stories placing it in late-19th-century New York and tying its rise to the era when vermouth and bitters helped shape the first great wave of mixed drinks. Whatever the exact beginning, you’ll find it endures because it’s simple, structured, and endlessly adaptable—especially in how you balance rye’s spice against bourbon’s rounder sweetness.</p> <p>On the palate, rye whiskey brings a firm, peppery backbone while bourbon adds a softer, sweeter depth that smooths the edges. Red vermouth threads through both with rich, winey sweetness, giving the drink its signature silky weight and a gently herbal finish. A dash of aromatic bitters tightens everything up, adding a dry, spiced snap that keeps the vermouth’s sweetness in check and makes the whiskey feel even more defined.</p> <p>Serve this in a chilled cocktail glass when you want something confident and unshowy—ideal for pre-dinner sipping or a slow, late-evening pour. You’ll love it if you’re drawn to spirit-forward drinks with a polished, bittersweet balance, or if you’re easing from straight whiskey into cocktails without losing that bold character.</p>
Ingredients
Method
How to make a Manhattan
- Rye whiskey 15ml, Bourbon 30ml, Red vermouth 30ml, Aromatic bitters 1 dash
-
- Begin by stirring all the ingredients together with ice in a mixing glass to chill and dilute the mix, aiming for about 10-15 seconds of stirring
-
- After stirring, strain the mixture into a glass that has been previously chilled in the freezer to ensure your drink stays colder longer
Cocktail glass
Microbadges
<p>The Cosmopolitan is a modern classic: a vodka-based sour brightened with citrus and cranberry, served up in a cocktail glass. You’ll often hear competing origin stories, but its most-cited modern form is linked to bartender Toby Cecchini at The Odeon in New York City in the late 1980s, refining an earlier “Cosmo” concept into the balanced, bar-ready drink people recognise today. It later becomes a pop-culture shorthand for sleek nights out, cementing its place on cocktail menus worldwide.</p> <p>On the palate, lemon vodka brings a clean, zesty backbone that lifts the whole drink. Cointreau adds orange sweetness and a subtle bitterness that rounds out the sharp edge of the lime juice, keeping the citrus from tasting one-note. Cranberry juice ties it together with a tart-sweet fruitiness, giving you that signature blush colour and a crisp, refreshing finish.</p> <p>This is the drink you reach for when you want something polished, lively, and easy to love—ideal before dinner, at celebrations, or anytime you’re in the mood for a citrus-forward cocktail that feels a little dressed up. If you enjoy bright, tangy flavours with a touch of sweetness, you’ll find it hits the spot without feeling heavy.</p>
Ingredients
Method
How to make a Cosmopolitan
- Lemon vodka 40 ml, Cointreau 15ml, Lime juice 15ml, Cranberry juice 30 ml
-
- Add all the ingredients to a cocktail shaker with plenty of ice, and shake until the outside of the shaker becomes frosted
-
- Strain into a cocktail glass and garnish with a twist of lemon peel before serving
Cocktail glass
Microbadges
<p>You’ll find the Daiquiri is the definitive rum sour: crisp, stripped-back, and built on a simple three-part balance of spirit, citrus, and sweetness. Its roots sit in Cuba, where it emerges as a practical, refreshing way to tame rum’s heat with lime and sugar, and it later becomes a calling card of the early 20th-century cocktail boom. As it travels beyond the island, it earns a reputation as a bartender’s benchmark—unforgiving in its simplicity, but brilliant when the balance is right.</p> <p>With white rum at the centre, you get a clean, lightly sweet cane character that carries the drink without weighing it down. Lime juice brings a sharp, mouthwatering acidity that snaps the rum into focus, while the sugar smooths the edges and rounds the citrus so it tastes bright rather than sour. Expect a tight, refreshing profile where each ingredient is clearly heard.</p> <p>Serve it in a cocktail glass when you want something brisk and elegant—an aperitif that wakes up your palate without feeling heavy. It suits warm evenings, pre-dinner drinks, and anyone who loves clean, citrus-led cocktails with a dry-leaning finish and no distractions.</p>
Pardon the interruption
Did you know that you can become a member for free, taking your cocktail making skills up to level 11. You can save your My Bar ingredients, make tasting notes, have personalised Tried and Want to try lists and more.
Ingredients
Method
How to make a Daiquiri
- White rum 60ml, Lime juice 20ml, Sugar 2 teaspoons
-
- Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker with ice
-
- Stir well to dissolve the sugar
-
- Shake well for 10-15 seconds or until the outside of the shaker becomes frosted
-
- Strain into a chilled cocktail glass and serve
Cocktail glass
Microbadges
<p>The Margarita is the definitive tequila sour: bright, bracing, and built around the classic balance of spirit, citrus, and orange liqueur. Its exact origin is famously disputed, with multiple mid‑20th‑century stories placing its rise on both sides of the US–Mexico border, but what’s clear is how quickly it becomes a modern staple—helping introduce tequila to a wider audience and cementing lime-and-orange as its most iconic pairing.</p> <p>With tequila blanco at the core, you’ll find clean agave character leading the way, sharpened by lime juice’s direct, mouthwatering acidity. Triple sec brings orange sweetness and a lightly candied citrus note that rounds the lime’s tart edge and smooths the tequila’s bite. A pinch of salt doesn’t make it “salty” so much as it lifts the citrus and makes the agave taste fuller and more vivid.</p> <p>Serve it when you want something crisp and confident—ideal as an aperitif, with spicy food, or anytime you’re craving a no-nonsense, citrus-forward drink. It suits drinkers who like their cocktails zesty and structured, with a clean finish that keeps you coming back for another sip.</p>
Ingredients
Method
How to make a Margarita
- Tequila blanco 50ml, Triple sec 20ml, Lime juice 15ml, Salt Pinch
-
- Rim the edge of a cocktail glass with salt by coating the edge with lime juice and dipping into the salt
-
- Add the other ingredients to a cocktail shaker with a few cubes of ice
-
- Shake well for 10-15 seconds or until the outside of the shaker becomes frosted
-
- Strain into a cocktail glass and serve
Filed with tags
Related posts
6 Cocktail-Making Tools You Definitely Need
The rules of mixology may be complicated, but the tools involved in cocktail-making are few and far between. It is possible to make an incredible drink using nothing but your required ingredients and...
The Science of Mixology: How to Perfect Your Home Bar Game with Expert Techniques
Are you tired of serving mediocre cocktails at your home gatherings? Want to take your mixology skills to the next level and impress your friends with expert techniques? Look no further – this article...
What Are The Different Types of Cocktail Shakers?
James Bond’s "shaken, not stirred" reference is synonymous with the history of cocktail shakers. Having been greatly influenced by the golden years of the cocktail himself, author Ian Fleming released...
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Get tips straight into your inbox.
Upgrade your mixology
Become a member for free taking your cocktail making skills up to level 11. Or become a premium member to rise to cocktail greatness.
- Save your bar forever
- Access to our Cocktail Creator, allowing you to create your own wonderful concoctions.
- Access to Cocktail Colin; ask Cocktail Colin anything on an individual cocktail and he'll give you the answers you need.
- Create personalised cocktail menus for all your events, bars or parties
- Save cocktails to personalised 'Tried' and 'Want to try' lists
- Create and record tasting notes on cocktails
- Create lists of cocktails to share with friends and family
- A personalised MyBar URL, allowing you to share everything you can make with friends
- And much more ... (what to buy next, measurement choices, search personalisation...)
Have you tried our Wordpress Plugin?
Download our plugin and embed cocktail recipes directly onto your own site or blog.
Choose from our whole recipe database, or choose a specific cocktail made with a certain ingredient, and let us place a beautiful recipe on your own site.
Find out more