Show me a drink that tastes like peanut butter.

If you're craving a cocktail with a rich, peanut butter-like flavor, the Banana Bread cocktail could be just what you're looking for. With a rating of 4.2/5, it's the highest-rated option among the ones we found. This sumptuous concoction combines Bailey's, Amaretto, Banana liqueur, Cream, and Frangelico to create a smooth, nutty, and creamy beverage that's reminiscent of banana bread — and by extension, it captures some of the comforting, nutty flavors you'd associate with peanut butter.

The mix of Amaretto and Frangelico provides a delightful nuttiness that closely mimics the taste of peanut butter, while the creaminess of Bailey's and Cream adds to the luxurious texture, much like spreading peanut butter on a piece of warm toast. This drink, served cold in a lowball glass, promises an indulgent and comforting experience that parallels the nostalgic joy of peanut butter.

Another option to consider is the Curtis's Nut Butter, rated 3.63/5. This cocktail blends Butterscotch schnapps, Amaretto, and Milk to create a creamy and velvety texture with a rich, nutty twist. The combination of butterscotch schnapps and Amaretto closely emulates the sweet and nutty flavor profile of peanut butter, topped with milk to enhance the overall creaminess. This drink is reminiscent of an alcoholic milkshake, making it another excellent choice for a peanut butter-like cocktail experience.