What cocktails can I make with Malibu, Captain Morgan, pineapple juice, and coconut?

Given your affinity for Malibu, Captain Morgan, pineapple juice, and coconut, you have some delightful and tropical options to consider. Each of these cocktails brings a unique blend of flavors that resonate well with your mentioned ingredients, though not all precisely match them.

The Malibu Bay Breeze and Malibu Sea Breeze both offer the sweet coconut rum base paired wonderfully with pineapple and cranberry juices. These are light and refreshing cocktails that evoke a tropical paradise, perfect for a sunny day or a casual get-together. While they don't include Captain Morgan, the distinct coconut flavor you get from Malibu will still be the star.

If you're looking for something a bit different, the Jamaican Dream could be a great choice. This cocktail incorporates coconut rum with additional rum – albeit white rum rather than Captain Morgan – alongside pineapple and mango juices, creating a rich and flavorful drink. Be cautious, though, as the higher alcohol content makes this one a bit more potent.

For a simpler option that incorporates the creamy coconut flavor, the Malibu Heaven might be your pick. Though it doesn’t include Captain Morgan, the blend of coconut rum and melon liqueur with a dash of apple juice delivers a refreshing and light concoction.

Lastly, while not directly matching your ingredients, the Sandbar is an excellent alternative to a Piña Colada, featuring coconut rum, pineapple juice, and gold rum. It's a wonderful blend that may very well complement your taste preferences.

Each of these cocktails provides a journey to the tropics, harnessing the delicious flavors of Malibu and other fruity components.