South of Brooklyn Cocktail recipe
Rating
South of Brooklyn sits in that modern, spirit-forward “Brooklyn-adjacent” family of cocktails, where rye leads and supporting players add depth and intrigue. While it doesn’t have a widely agreed, long-established origin story, it reads like a contemporary riff built for drinkers who enjoy the Manhattan/Brooklyn style of balance—boozy, aromatic, and layered—served up in a coupe for a crisp, focused sip.
You’ll find rye whiskey’s dry spice at the core, with dark rum lending a deeper, rounder sweetness that softens the edges. Amaro brings a firm bittersweet backbone, while maraschino cherry liqueur adds a small but distinctive lift of sweet cherry-almond richness. White vermouth contributes gentle herbal sweetness, and the white wine lightens the mid-palate with a clean, vinous snap. A dash of Peychaud’s aromatic bitters ties it together with bright, perfumed bitterness that keeps the finish taut.
Serve this when you want something contemplative and grown-up—ideal as a pre-dinner sipper or a late-evening pour. It suits fans of rye cocktails who also like amaro-driven complexity, and it’s a great choice when you’re in the mood for elegance without overt citrus or heavy sweetness.
Microbadges
Method
How to make a South of Brooklyn
- Rye whiskey 20 ml, Dark rum 10 ml, Amaro 10 ml, Maraschino cherry liqueur 5 ml, White wine 20 ml, White vermouth 10 ml, Peychaud's Aromatic Bitters 1 dash
-
- Begin by chilling a Nick & Nora glass
-
- In a mixing glass filled with ice, combine all ingredients: rye whiskey, white wine, dark rum, white vermouth, amaro, maraschino liqueur, and bitters
-
- Stir until well-chilled
-
- Strain into the prepared glass
-
- Express the orange zest over the drink, discard the peel, and garnish with a skewered maraschino cherry
Power tips
Elevate the South of Brooklyn with these master mixologist tips
Upgrade to premium
And receive world class tips on how to raise your cocktails to the next level.
Find out more- To enhance the aromatics of this cocktail, consider 'flaming' the orange zest before expressing it over the drink. Hold the peel over the glass, skin side pointing towards the liquid, and briefly wave a flame over the peel. Express the oils into the flame; this will caramelize the oils slightly and impart a subtle, toasted aroma to the drink.
- Chill your coupe glass in the freezer for at least 15 minutes before starting the cocktail preparation. This will ensure that the cocktail maintains its optimal temperature when served, enhancing its vibrant flavors and textures.
- Upgrade to premium to receive even more power tips on this cocktail.
Your private tasting notes
FAQ's
What is the origin of the South of Brooklyn cocktail?
The South of Brooklyn cocktail is a modern creation, debuting in March 2025, that puts a fresh twist on the classic Brooklyn cocktail. Invented as a nod to the geographical relationship between Brooklyn and the Caribbean, it brings together the robust flavors of aged Caribbean rum and rye whiskey, with the added complexity of white vermouth and maraschino liqueur. This cocktail represents a delightful fusion of New York City's cosmopolitan edge with the warm, rich traditions of island culture. Its name cheekily reflects the placement of the Caribbean relative to Brooklyn, offering a playful yet sophisticated narrative to its drinkers.
What role does rye whiskey play in the South of Brooklyn cocktail?
In the South of Brooklyn cocktail, rye whiskey serves as the backbone of the drink, providing a bold and robust base that anchors the other flavors. Known for its spicy and slightly fruity notes, rye whiskey brings depth and complexity to this cocktail. It complements the sweeter elements from the maraschino liqueur and dark rum, balancing the overall flavor profile. The choice of rye, rather than a softer spirit like bourbon, ensures that the cocktail maintains its edgy, refined taste, in line with its New York inspiration.
What is the best way to garnish a South of Brooklyn cocktail?
To garnish a South of Brooklyn cocktail, the classic approach involves a maraschino cherry and a twist of orange zest. The maraschino cherry adds a touch of sweetness and visual appeal as it gently rests at the bottom of the coupe glass. Meanwhile, the twist of orange zest releases aromatic oils that enhance the cocktail's complexity with citric notes, while also providing a fresh, fragrant bouquet as the drink is served. This garnish not only complements the bitters and vermouth but also elevates the sensory experience, making the cocktail both aesthetically pleasing and richly flavorful.
How does the alcohol content of the South of Brooklyn compare to other cocktails?
The South of Brooklyn cocktail boasts an alcohol content of 23.9%, which places it on the stronger end of the cocktail spectrum. This is due to its potent mix of spirits including rye whiskey, dark rum, and white vermouth. In comparison to more mainstream cocktails like a typical Mojito or Margarita, which usually have around 10-15% alcohol content, the South of Brooklyn is significantly stronger. This makes it an excellent choice for those seeking a cocktail with complex flavors and a bold profile, while also being mindful of consumption and pacing during social gatherings.
What food pairs well with the South of Brooklyn cocktail?
The South of Brooklyn cocktail pairs wonderfully with foods that can complement and balance its rich, layered flavors. Its robust profile, marked by spice from the rye and richness from the rum, pairs well with dishes featuring strong, flavorful ingredients. Consider pairing it with a charcuterie board featuring spicy cured meats and aged cheeses, which can highlight the cocktail's complexity. Additionally, dishes with mild sweetness, such as honey-glazed roasted poultry or caramelized nuts, can mirror the subtle sweetness of the maraschino liqueur, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Upgrade your mixology
Become a member for free taking your cocktail making skills up to level 11. Or become a premium member to rise to cocktail greatness.
- Save your bar forever
- Access to our Cocktail Creator, allowing you to create your own wonderful concoctions.
- Access to Cocktail Colin; ask Cocktail Colin anything on an individual cocktail and he'll give you the answers you need.
- Create personalised cocktail menus for all your events, bars or parties
- Save cocktails to personalised 'Tried' and 'Want to try' lists
- Create and record tasting notes on cocktails
- Create lists of cocktails to share with friends and family
- A personalised MyBar URL, allowing you to share everything you can make with friends
- And much more ... (what to buy next, measurement choices, search personalisation...)
Have you tried our Wordpress Plugin?
Download our plugin and embed cocktail recipes directly onto your own site or blog.
Choose from our whole recipe database, or choose a specific cocktail made with a certain ingredient, and let us place a beautiful recipe on your own site.
Find out moreYou might also like
Experience this blend of rye and dual vermouth
Perfect Manhattan
Rye whiskey, Red vermouth, White vermouth, Aromatic bitters
Experience this timeless blend of rye and vermouth.
Ann Sheridan
Rye whiskey, Cointreau, Red vermouth
Uncover this bold fusion of whiskey and Amaro
Island Voodoo
Rye whiskey, Lemon liqueur, Amaro
Indulge in this rich and creamy holiday treat.
Christmas Pudding Cream
Rye whiskey, Creme de cacao, Bailey's, Frangelico
Create a cocktail
Choose a theme and some ingredients, give us some description and we'll create an amazing cocktail for you.
Register as a Premium Make Me a Cocktail community member and get access to an even more powerful creator.
Start creatingBuild your bar
Tell us what you have at home and we'll find a delicious cocktail for you to make right now.
Register as a Make Me a Cocktail community member and we'll save your ingredients list so you can come back to it at any time.
Create My Bar
Cocktail Colin
Your cocktail expert
Hi! I'm Cocktail Colin
Ask me anything about this cocktail - how to make it, substitutions, variations, or any other questions!
Become a member to access Cocktail Colin
Become a member (for free) to pick Cocktail Colin's cocktail filled brain on everything on this cocktail, from substitutions, if you can use what you have, to serving suggestions and more.
Become a member
Comments